It's a pity they didn't have the drovers dog in there. I would expect he would be up there, with a similat share.
2
Tuesday, 13 October 2009 22:57
Mitch
I put Peter Dutton as #1 purely because I'd never heard of him. Turnbull, Costello, Abbott, Bishop and Hockey are all falling stars from the Howard era. If the Liberals want to resurrect their party, they need a few new faces.
3
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 06:03
Garry
The current crop of ex Howard and Workchoice tainted Liberal/National politicians have in the eyes of the Australian electorate the "Sword of Damacles" hanging over them. Whilst they keep harking back to the "mentally stale,old, divisive and morally out of touch" Howard ball and chain government then they are just plain and simply un-electable or even able to present as an effective Opposition.
4
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 07:04
Denis Connell
It turns out that Turnbull was a bad choice by the " party room" but what will they do next?? I am not sure that there can emerge a true consensus which will be acceptable to all
5
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 07:33
Dee
The Liberal Party both State & Federal need a LARGE number of new faces - and to remember what the Liberal Party stands for, not what individual "Leaders" (& would be "Leaders") interpretations are of The Liberal Party - interpretations for their own aggrandisment.
6
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 07:44
Jacqui
It has turned out that Turnbull was a bad choice, but what next? My first thought on looking at the six choices given in the survey was, "isn't there anyone else?" But it appears there isn't. None of them looked promising to me.
7
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 07:51
Margaret
Give Turnbull the support and you will find he will make a great leader, remember John Howard the flack he got and he is now remembered as one of Australia's best PM's
8
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 07:52
Carolyn Cordon
I would have loved to see Costello as PM, but that chance has gone. I feel like spin and swish have taken over and good strong belief systems have nothing to do with politics anymore.
9
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 08:54
jack
Of course like all these surveys about leadership the only info available about the non office holders is "doorstop" impressions and not the in depth knowledge available to those who may have to make an actual decision on the matter. e.g. way back when he was a junior minister in the Howard government Joe had to be moved from looking after the ABS because he could not get his head around what a standard error was. Also emerging to take the token Julie Bishop job is Helen Coonan and what a success she was taking over from Alston. What hope for the libs?...No hope!
10
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 09:04
cami
It is time for the Coalition to come up with their policies if they are going to succeed at all. Negative attacks on the Government which by the way is performing well in every aspect is not going to take them anywhere. All their reps keep saying is that they gave over a 20 billion nest egg to this government but everyone knows how they did this and also by making it very difficult for the poor worker so now it is their turn to fight for government in a positive way and I do not see them doing this for some time.
11
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 09:29
PPalloy
I don't care who is leader of the Liberals.
12
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 11:37
Matthew Little
I would gone for Costello, but the others no.
13
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 12:50
GeeJay
Malcolm would be a good leader if he could get rid of the white ants in his party...
14
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 13:17
Des
It is hard to believe that the libs have sunk to such lows. The most grossly ineffective opposition I have ever seen. Maybe they are paying the price for allowing Howard to have such power. Most are (as a previous poster said) tainted with the former government. Turnbull's animosity towards Rudd has been very clear from day one. His determination to discredit anything that labor has done regardless, has shown him to be completely incompetent. This animosity towards Rudd has backfired with the public. I am a Labor voter, but would like to see an effective opposition.
15
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 13:35
Bern
While Malcom Turnbull supports an ETS scheme that is nothing short of a tax, I believe he is out of touch with the ordinary Australian. Neither do I want Joe Hockey to run the country as he has no respect for the stay at home mother nor do I like his lack of morals. Bring on Tony Abbott, a man of high moral principles.
16
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 14:24
Bagsy
Any Government needs a responsible and strong Opposition, who just does not oppose for the sake of opposition, but has a coherent view on issues and a distinct set of p[olicies. At present the Coalition has lost its way. Partly because Howard years drained them of any flow of ideas other than been drys
17
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 15:12
Allie
Can't believe people have such short memories regarding the Liberal Party and the hacks during the Howard years. Dutton was the little upstart that took the axe to every section of the social security, including the disability allowance. We are still waiting for the erasure of most of what he did that hurt so many families but also made individuals ( through no fault of their own) to feel ashamed and frightened with the threats being directed from Centrelink put in place by Dutton.
18
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 17:28
Rob
The Liberals are in a tight spot. The ALP - in many ways more Liberal than the Liberal Party has taken the slightly right of centre on the political spectrum. The Liberal party under Howard developed a strong hard right flavour. However, in Australian politics extremes of left or right are not embraced by a large section of voters. It is hard to see where the Liberal party can go to crawl back votes from the ALP. In some respects it is the Greens who have become the real opposition or alternative view to the Rudd government in the absence of any real clear alternative policies from within the divided Liberal party.
19
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 19:34
Chris
I forgot to mention that one of the biggest challenges is the intrusion of religion into public life. Thumbs down for rudd Abbott and costello on that front
20
Wednesday, 14 October 2009 19:51
Stewart_in_Oz
Where is Guy Fox when we need him? For Chris who is 'presumably' A-religious. If you have nothing to base your opinion on, whether moral or spiritual, then your opinion is purely subjective and that sort of opinion is flawed. As has been said "when a man stops believing in GOD, he doesn't believe nothing, he believes anything and everything." Our politicians are bad enough even with the veneer of religion that you seem to object to the intrusion thereof.
21
Thursday, 15 October 2009 00:15
Richard
What goes on with the liberal party, Turnbull etc,is largely irrelevant. What is relevant is that Rudd is laying the foudations for theworst ever govt this countryhas ever seen. He will make the N.S.W. govt look competent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.His bullshit is the same as Carr's. Just wait,all will be clear very soon. Ask yourselves "Who is going to find/pay/borrow the $500 BILLION to bail out the totally bankrupt/insolvent state of N.S.W. & ,TO build the needed infrastructure to resusitate it's choking economy.
22
Thursday, 15 October 2009 04:47
Ronald Kitching
I do not favour Turnbull, Hockey nor Abbott. None of them have a classical Liberal bone in their bodies. They are all professional politicians who will do anything for a vote. Out of those on the horizon I favour Julie Bishop. but she too lacks any knowledge or expertise in the Classical Liberal tradition.The Liberal party needs to be rebuilt in true Classical Liberal traditions, a philosophy that is sadly missed in this Nation.
23
Thursday, 15 October 2009 05:51
janice
There is no potential credible opposition leader in sight at this time. They might as well keep Malcolm Turnbull and make an effort to put their petty schoolyard fights aside. After a couple more terms, some sound candidate selection and a lot of hard work formulating policies, a real leader will emerge.
24
Thursday, 15 October 2009 07:31
Jenny Sams
There is no solution for a leader for the Liberals. Turnbull is a spent force, like a dead man walking, he has no control of his party. Hockey is lazy, a follower and not a leader, he is no solution at all. Abbott is not even in contention, he has too many times shown his true colours, he would be forever in the single digit category like Nelson was.Dutton is a goose with no guts, read Dickson bail out. Bishop does not handle matters very well, this is evident of how she sometimes get simple issues quite wrong.
25
Thursday, 15 October 2009 13:01
peter
Questions like ‘who do you prefer definitely need an ‘irrelevant’ or ‘none of the above’, option.
The problem we are seeing in the liberals at the moment is a symptom of a flawed system.
The two party, compulsory voting system makes for lazy, incompetent politicians. What is needed is the Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) as adopted by New Zealand, with one additional tag, prohibiting coalition governments — which are nothing but attempts to cram it back into a two party system.
And do away with compulsory voting and the approximately $2 payment for each primary vote.
26
Thursday, 15 October 2009 17:54
Michael
And I had such high hopes that with Malcolm Turnbull either as PM or good ppositon Leader that the Republic debate would get a guernsey.
27
Friday, 16 October 2009 04:20
David
The Liberals are a rabble. Simple as that. No effective policy statements,intellectually inferior to the Government and still reeling from the stench of the Howard era. Count Rudd in for at least 3 terms.
28
Monday, 19 October 2009 00:49
Serge
Turnbull could never make a good leader because all he craves is power. He has never elucidated any sort of vision for Australia nor does he seem to have any particular politically ideological conviction. Who knows what he believes in. I'm sure he would've been just as happy as leader of the Labor Party.
Turnbull's animosity towards Rudd has been very clear from day one. His determination to discredit anything that labor has done regardless, has shown him to be completely incompetent. This animosity towards Rudd has backfired with the public.
I am a Labor voter, but would like to see an effective opposition.
Dutton was the little upstart that took the axe to every section of the social security, including the disability allowance. We are still waiting for the erasure of most of what he did that hurt so many families but also made individuals ( through no fault of their own) to feel ashamed and frightened with the threats being directed from Centrelink put in place by Dutton.
For Chris who is 'presumably' A-religious. If you have nothing to base your opinion on, whether moral or spiritual, then your opinion is purely subjective and that sort of opinion is flawed. As has been said "when a man stops believing in GOD, he doesn't believe nothing, he believes anything and everything."
Our politicians are bad enough even with the veneer of religion that you seem to object to the intrusion thereof.
The problem we are seeing in the liberals at the moment is a symptom of a flawed system.
The two party, compulsory voting system makes for lazy, incompetent politicians. What is needed is the Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) as adopted by New Zealand, with one additional tag, prohibiting coalition governments — which are nothing but attempts to cram it back into a two party system.
And do away with compulsory voting and the approximately $2 payment for each primary vote.